Kushnick | Pallaci PLLC Attorney At Law

The Mechanic’s Lien in New York: Weighing the Pros and Cons

The Mechanic’s Lien in New York: Weighing the Pros and Cons

Share This Post

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on email

When it comes to securing payment for construction work, mechanics’ liens can be a powerful tool for contractors and suppliers in New York. A mechanic’s lien provides a legal claim on a property to ensure that those who have contributed to its improvement are compensated. However, like any legal remedy, there are both advantages and disadvantages to consider. In this blog post, we will explore the pros and cons of filing and enforcing a mechanic’s lien in the state of New York.

Pros of Filing and Enforcing a Mechanic’s Lien

  1. Secures Payment: The primary benefit of a mechanic’s lien is its ability to secure payment for contractors and suppliers. It ensures that those who have invested time, labor, and materials in a construction project are not left unpaid. When the property owner refuses or delays payment, the lien serves as a powerful incentive for them to settle the outstanding debt.
  2. Priority Over Other Creditors: Mechanic’s liens often take priority over other creditors, even subsequent mortgage holders. This means that in the event of the property owner’s bankruptcy or foreclosure, the contractors and suppliers with a valid lien may have a better chance of recovering their dues compared to unsecured creditors.
  3. Encourages Fairness in Payment: The presence of mechanics’ liens can foster fair payment practices in the construction industry. Contractors and suppliers are more likely to be paid promptly when property owners know that a lien could be filed against their property for non-payment.
  4. Legal Protection for Contractors: Filing a mechanic’s lien provides legal protection to contractors and suppliers who might otherwise face financial losses due to non-payment or project abandonment.
  5. Leads to Settlement Negotiations: Once a mechanic’s lien is filed, it often triggers discussions between the parties involved. Property owners may seek to resolve the dispute to avoid the negative consequences of the lien, leading to potential settlements that benefit all parties.

Cons of Filing and Enforcing a Mechanic’s Lien

  1. Complex Legal Process: Filing and enforcing a mechanic’s lien in New York can be a complex legal process. The documentation, deadlines, and requirements must be meticulously followed. Any errors or omissions in the lien can render it invalid.
  2. Costs and Time-Consuming: Initiating a mechanic’s lien requires financial investment in legal representation and court fees. Additionally, the process may take several months to resolve, leading to prolonged payment delays for contractors and suppliers.
  3. Potential Litigation: If the property owner disputes the validity of the lien, it may lead to costly and time-consuming litigation. Contractors and suppliers should be prepared to defend their claims in court.
  4. No Guarantee of Payment: While a mechanic’s lien improves the chances of payment, it does not guarantee full recovery of outstanding dues. If the property owner lacks sufficient funds to satisfy all debts, contractors may still receive less than the total amount owed.
  5. Damage to Business Relationships: Pursuing a mechanic’s lien can strain business relationships between contractors/suppliers and property owners. It may impact future collaboration opportunities, especially if the dispute becomes acrimonious.


Mechanic’s liens can be a valuable tool for contractors and suppliers in New York, offering a legal remedy to secure payment for their services and materials. However, they also come with potential drawbacks, including the complexity of the process, costs, and the possibility of damaging business relationships. Before deciding to file and enforce a mechanic’s lien, parties should carefully consider the specific circumstances and consult with legal professionals to understand their rights, obligations, and alternatives to resolve payment disputes.

More To Explore

Kushnick | Pallaci PLLC Attorney At Law​

Need Help With a Legal Issue?

From contracts, to payment application disputes to construction defect claims we can help.  We can often assess your situation and your options during a free initial consultation. Contact us at (631) 752-7100 or (212) 752-7155 to schedule an appointment or contact us via the web by clicking here.