Kushnick | Pallaci PLLC Attorney At Law

“Trivial” defects not grounds for holding general contractor liable to worker injured on construction site

“Trivial” defects not grounds for holding general contractor liable to worker injured on construction site

Share This Post

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on email

In Madero v. Pizzagalli Construciton Co., a worker was injured when he fell over an alleged defect in concrete that apparently was recently poured. During depositions it was determined, and it was uncontested, that the alleged defect was “tiny.” One of the witnesses placed a business card over a nickel and folded the corners or the card down and stated that the bump created by the nickel accurately described the size of the “defect” that the worker claimed to have been injured by. While the trial court denied the general contractor’s motion for summary judgment, the Appellate Division reversed and found that a defect can be trivial as a matter of law and that the circumstances here warranted a finding, as a matter of law, that the defect was trivial and that the plaintiff therefore was not entitled to recovery. In determining that the defect was trivial the court took into consideration the fact that the “defect” alleged was a common condition in construction sites at that phase in construction.

Vincent T. Pallaci is a New York construction lawyer.  He can be reached at vtp@nyconstructionlaw.com

More To Explore

Judicial License Agreements in NYC Webinar

Watch and listen to Kushnick Pallaci Managing Partner Vincent Pallaci discuss Judicial License Agreements in NYC in today’s Construction Law Webinar. You can learn more

Kushnick | Pallaci PLLC Attorney At Law​

Need Help With a Legal Issue?

From contracts, to payment application disputes to construction defect claims we can help.  We can often assess your situation and your options during a free initial consultation. Contact us at (631) 752-7100 or (212) 752-7155 to schedule an appointment or contact us via the web by clicking here.